Five Points Cafe Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Five Points Cafe, a vibrant culinary destination nestled in Sayville, NY. With a menu that bursts with flavor, this cafe offers a delightful variety of options that cater to every palate. From the zesty Cajun chicken sandwich to the comforting Reuben, each dish is crafted with attention to detail and freshness.
Pair your meal with a glass of Chardonnay or indulge in one of their creative cocktails, like the refreshing Rose Lemonade, perfect for sipping on a warm afternoon. The inviting atmosphere, complete with attentive service and live music, enhances every dining experience.
Five Points Cafe truly excels in making every visit memorable, whether you’re dining with friends, enjoying a night out, or relaxing on their pet-friendly patio. Join us for a journey of flavors that you'll surely want to repeat!
White Wines
Piot Grigio Ballata, Veneto, Italy
Pale straw color, fresh & fruity with a crisp clean finish.
Chardonnay Vintage Oaks, California
Light straw color, aromas of tropical fruit and citrus and pear flavors.
Sauvignon Blanc Prophecy, New Zealand
Flavors of grapefruit, lychee and Meyer lemon offer crisp, citrus refreshment.
Moscato Pellegrino, Sicily, Italy
Sweet & delicate wine with floral bouquet and fresh peach flavors.
Rose Juliette, France
Refreshing and crisp rose wine with layers of lively fruit and a bright, smooth finish.
Cabernet Sauvignon Robert Hall, California
Black currant, hints of cedar and spice, full bodied with rich and velvety tannins.
Malbec Herencia Trabajo, Mendoza, Argentina
Deep garnet red with aromas and flavors of dark cherry and chocolate, elegant soft tannins.
Pinot Noir Townhouse, California
Well-balanced displaying opulent fruit with jammy flavors of boysenberries, raspberries & cherries.
Red Wines
Sangria
Red Sangria
White Sangria
Bud Light, USA
Stella Artois, Belgium
Bluepoint Brewing Toasted Lager, USA
Guinness, Ireland
IPA
Seasonal
On Tap
Bottle
Michelob Ultra, USA
Heineken / Heineken Light, Holland
Corona / Corona Light, Mexico
Miller Lite
Non-Alcoholic
Downtown Mojito/ Strawberry / Coconut
Fresh mint and limes muddled with Bacardi rum, simple syrup, club soda
Blood Orange Paloma
Silver tequila, lime juice, simple syrup, fresh blood orange juice, club soda, tajin rim
Cherry Grove Punch
Malibu rum, peach schnapps, triple sec, orange juice, pineapple, grenadine, sprite
Rose Lemonade
Rose wine, lemonade, splash club soda
Whiskey Peach Tea
Jim Beam, peach schnapps, triple sec, sweet tea
Limoncello Spritz
Prosecco, Limoncello, Club Soda, Fresh mint
Jalapeno Mule
Jalapeno infused tequila, lime, ginger beer
Downtown Lemonade
Stoli Razz, Blue curacao & lemonade
Jalapeno & Cucumber Margarita
Spicy tequila, muddled cucumbers, lime juice, triple sec, sour, tajin rim
Mango Margarita
Yave mango tequila, lime, cointreau, sour mix, tajin rim
Cocktails
Martinis
Cucumber-Tini
Crops cucumber vodka, St. Germaine, lemonade
Coconut-Tini
Malibu rum, vanilla vodka, creme de coconut, splash OJ, coconut flakes
Blood Orange Tini
Felene vodka, Cointreau, Lime juice, Fresh Blood Orange juice
Watermelon Cosmo
Watermelon vodka, lime juice, triple sec, splash cranberry
Blood Orange Margarita
Strawberry Margarita
Coconut Margarita
Classic Margarita
Margaritas
Spiked Milkshakes
Mudslide
Kahlua, vanilla vodka, irish cream, vanilla ice cream
Chocolate Colada
Silver rum, coco lopez, chocolate ice cream
Strawberries & Cream
Vodka, strawberry puree, irish cream, vanilla ice cream
Snickers
Caramel Vodka, Chocolate Liquor, chocolate ice cream